Monday 14 January 2013

Hybrid Vehicle & EMF Part 4: Final Verdict

After Part 1, Part 2 and Part 3 information, here is my personal final verdict:

  1. I do believe EMF in hybrid car is safe for now. BUT, there are many unknown the scientist has yet to discover, I will be cautious on it and may purchase some protective gadget.
  2. When selecting a hybrid car take note on the AC/DC (DC is better), voltage (lower is better), electricity current (lower is better) and most important the distance of the battery pack from the passenger (further is better), to minimize the potential risk.
  3. Try not to use hybrid car for long duration (hours) frequently.

I did a few days of survey on the EMF protective gadget:
  1. http://www.lessemf.com/magnetic_shielding.html, effectiveness should be good but with high price tag.
  2. There are few from Amazon, but I doubt their effectiveness as there is no sufficient scientific data as evidence (EMF meter can't detect a reduction in field strength reading), but with good testimonial from customers:
Most probably I can't try all the above, as convert to Malaysia currency and add up the international shipping cost, it is out of my budget.

I also discover an interesting product in Malaysia online shopping web site called I-Protech Energy Neutralizer EMF Radiation Reduction, it reduces the EMF meter EMF strength reading, which is unseen from any resonator. You may want to take a look on the video in the product selling page.

For now my target is to try out good quality charcoal (yes, CHARCOAL), from this blog, charcoal has the natural ability to dissipate Electromagnetic (EM) Fields. Definitely I will buy when I visit Singapore, product from Taketaro looks promising.

Hybrid Vehicle & EMF Part 3: EMF In Hybrid Vehicle

Let's do a recap on the electrical property of hybrid car
Car Model
Electric
Motor Type
Motor
Output (kW)
Battery
Voltage (V)
Current
( A = W/V)
Toyota Prius
AC
27
201.6
134
Toyota Prius C
AC
19.3
144
134
Honda Civic Hybrid
DC
20
108 - 172
116 - 185
Honda Jazz Hybrid
DC
10
100.8
99

Some guess works:
  1. It is DC between the battery packs and the electric motor.
  2. There is no step-down or step-up in both voltage and current between the battery pack and electric motor. Any step-down and step-up will cause heat and energy loss.a
Although multiple study show that there is no evidence of health risk on low frequency EMF, is it really the case for hybrid car, where you are so near to the EMF source, in an enclosed metal cage (like in a microwave oven) and expose for long duration?

In early 2010, Israel Ministry of Environment Protection is expected to publish the results of the study this week. The study will group hybrids sold in Israel into three different radiation groups, reports Israel’s Calcalist. It’s expected that the current-gen Prius will be deemed ‘safe’, while the Honda Insight and Civic Hybrid (as well as the prev-gen Prius) will be listed as emitting ‘excessive’ radiation. Recently, the research committee stirred the public conscious as it advised the Israeli Police against adding hybrid cars to its mostly diesel powered fleet, due to medical hazards to officers exposed to radiation for lengthy periods of time. (Source: The Truth About Cars)

Quote from Wikipedia:
However, Toyota[136] and several independent studies[137][138] have indicated that aside from a brief spike when accelerating, the electromagnetic fields within the Prius are no different from those of a conventional car and do not exceed the ICNIRP[139] exposure guidelines.

Sound alarming? BUT Consumer Reports released a study on car EMF level in mid year 2010, surprisingly they found non-hybrid car generally generate higher EMF compare to hybrid car.

Also information from Japan EMF Information Center, indicated that EMF in hybrid car is within the safe level: Assessments of exposure to magnetic fields of hybrid cars and electric cars were reported at the BioEM 2009 Meeting held in June 2009 (jointly hosted by the European BioElectromagnetics Association (EBEA) and the Bioelectromagentics Society (BEMS)). The result of measuring EMF of direct current to 100-Hz frequencies leads to the conclusion that "the average exposure was within 5% of the reference level for the public specified in the ICNIRP guidelines(1998) and the maximum value was up to about 15% of the reference level."

Sunday 13 January 2013

Hybrid Vehicle & EMF Part 2: EMF

What is EMF?

EMF stands for Electromagnetic fields, it consists of electric and magnetic field.

Quote from WHO: Electric fields are created by difference in voltage: the higher the voltage, the stronger will be the resultant field. Magnetic fields are created when electric current flows: the greater the current, the stronger the magnetic field. An electric field will exist even when there is no current flowing. If current does flow, the strength of the magnetic field will vary with power consumption but the electric field strength will be constant.



How does EMF strength and effect correlate with AC/DC, voltage, current?

Quote from WHO: 
EMF fields of different frequencies interact with the body in different ways, the higher the frequency the shorter the wavelength. Higher frequency (shorter wavelength) waves carry more energy than lower frequency (longer wavelength) fields. Some electromagnetic waves carry so much energy that they have the ability to break bonds between molecules. In the electromagnetic spectrum, gamma rays given off by radioactive materials, cosmic rays and X-rays carry this property and are called 'ionizing radiation'. Fields that are insufficient to break molecular bonds are called 'non-ionizing radiation'.
Electric Fields
Magnetic Fields
Electric fields arise from voltage. An electric field can be present even when a device is switched off.
Magnetic fields arise from current flows.  Magnetic fields exist as soon as a device is switched on and current flows.
Strength is measured in Volts per meter (V/m)
Strength is measured in amperes per meter (A/m). Commonly, EMF investigators use a related measure, flux density (in microtesla (µT) or millitesla (mT) instead.
Field strength decreases with distance from the source.
Field strength decreases with distance from the source.
Most building materials shield electric fields to some extent.
Magnetic fields are not attenuated by most materials.

Quote from Canadian Electricity Association: 
EMF is dependent upon line voltage, loads and current in a power line. The fields are highest directly under/over the power line and quickly become weaker as one moves away from the center line.
Earth does produce static magnetic field of strengths up to 500 mG. Since these are DC or static fields, their potential interaction with the human body would be different (as compare to AC fields).
Static electric and magnetic fields associated with DC transmission lines are not viewed as a health concern. Their levels are very low and similar to the naturally occurring static fields we are exposed to in our daily lives.

Quote from Atco Electric: The Difference Between AC and DC Fields. The modern electric power system operates using alternating current (AC) almost exclusively. AC changes polarity or “cycles” 60 times a second. Its fields also cycle at 60 Hz and are referred to as Extremely Low Frequency (ELF) fields. Direct current (DC) is constant, like current from a battery. Its electric and magnetic fields are also constant (frequency of zero) and are referred to as static fields.

Quote from Japan EMF Information Center:



How does EMF strength and effect correlate with distance?

Quote from WHO:
Typical electric field strengths measured near household appliances (at a distance of 30 cm):
Electric appliance
Electric field strength (V/m)
Stereo receiver
180
Iron
120
Refrigerator
120
Mixer
100
Toaster
80
Hair dryer
80
Color TV
60
Coffee machine
60
Vacuum cleaner
50
Electric oven
8
Light bulb
5
Guideline limit value of 5000 V/m.

Typical magnetic field strength of household appliances at various distances
Electric appliance
3 cm distance (µT)
30 cm distance (µT)
1 m distance (µT)
Hair dryer
6 – 2000
0.01 – 7
0.01 – 0.03
Electric shaver
15 – 1500
0.08 – 9
0.01 – 0.03
Vacuum cleaner
200 – 800
2 – 20
0.13 – 2
Fluorescent light
40 – 400
0.5 – 2
0.02 – 0.25
Microwave oven
73 – 200
4 – 8
0.25 – 0.6
Portable radio
16 – 56
1
< 0.01
Electric oven
1 – 50
0.15 – 0.5
0.01 – 0.04
Washing machine
0.8 – 50
0.15 – 3
0.01 – 0.15
Iron
8 – 30
0.12 – 0.3
0.01 – 0.03
Dishwasher
3.5 – 20
0.6 – 3
0.07 – 0.3
Computer
0.5 – 30
< 0.01

Refrigerator
0.5 – 1.7
0.01 – 0.25
<0.01
Colour TV
2.5 - 50
0.04 – 2
0.01 – 0.15
Guideline limit for the general public of 100 µT.

Quote from Atco Electric:
MRI machines
1.4-4 million µT
Battery operated appliances
300-1000 µT
Electrified railways
Up to 100 µT
Typical 500 kV DC transmission line (within the right-of-way)
10-57 µT
It does not mention the distance of measurement, but it does give a good picture the amount of magnetic fields around your environment.


Is low frequency EMF harmful?

Quote from WHO:
The absence of health effects could mean that there really are none; however, it could also signify that an existing effect is undetectable with present methods.
Results of diverse studies (cellular, animal, and epidemiology) must be considered together before drawing conclusions about possible health risks of a suspected environmental hazard. Consistent evidence from these very different types of studies increases the degree of certainty about a true effect.

Quote from Atco Electric:
Static electric and magnetic fields associated with DC transmission lines are not viewed as a health concern.
Their levels are very low and similar to the naturally occurring static fields we are exposed to in our daily lives. Static electric fields cannot penetrate animal or plant tissues; they can only create a static charge on the surface.
The bulk of scientific research on electric and magnetic fields has focused on AC or higher frequency fields generated by microwave communications and X-rays. Their characteristics are very different from those of static fields.The International Commission on Electromagnetic Safety, which has one of the lowest levels for public exposure, recommends a public exposure guideline of 1,180,000 mG. By comparison, the static magnetic field produced by a typical 500 kV DC line is estimated at up to 570 mG directly beneath the line.
Health Canada, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation Protection (ICNIRP) evaluate and report on public and occupational health issues using comprehensive and unbiased weight-of-evidence reviews of the research available. Their reviews have concluded that the risk to human health from static electric and magnetic fields produced by DC lines is very low.

During the 1990s, most EMF research focused on extremely low frequency exposures stemming from conventional power sources, such as power lines, electrical substations, or home appliances. While some of these studies showed a possible link between EMF field strength and an increased risk for childhood leukemia, their findings indicated that such an association was weak.
Now, in the age of cellular telephones, wireless routers, and portable GPS devices (all known sources of EMF radiation), concerns regarding a possible connection between EMFs and adverse health effects still persists, though current research continues to point to the same weak association.
Additionally, the few studies that have been conducted on adults show no evidence of a link between EMF exposure and adult cancers, such as leukemia, brain cancer, and breast cancer. Nevertheless, NIEHS recommends continued education on practical ways of reducing exposures to EMFs.

Quote from Japan EMF Information Center:
WHO Fact Sheet No. 296 (Electromagnetic hypersensitivity, EHS) reports that "the symptoms most commonly experienced include dermatological symptoms (redness, tingling, and burning sensations) as well as neurasthenic and vegetative symptoms (fatigue, tiredness, concentration difficulties, dizziness, nausea, heart palpitations, and digestive disturbances)." Some people allege that such symptoms are related to EMF exposure.


Summaries:

  1. Electric fields are not a concern as it cannot penetrate animal or plant tissues.
  2. The further from the source the smaller the field strength and its effect.
  3. Low frequency (AC) EMF fields are riskier than static (DC) EMF fields.
  4. There is no evidence to link health risk to EMF; at the same time there is no evidence to prove EMF does not has health risk!! Thus, NIEHS recommends continued education on practical ways of reducing exposures to EMFs.
  5. Electromagnetic hypersensitivity (EHS), do you have it?

What do the car manufacturers say about EMF of their Hybrid car? Is there any independent organization measure EMF in Hybrid car?

Hybrid Vehicle & EMF Part 1: Hybrid Vehicle

Quote from Wikipedia: A Hybrid Vehicle is a vehicle that uses two or more distinct power sources to move the vehicle. The term most commonly refers to hybrid electric vehicles, which combine an internal combustion engine and one or more electric motors.

Let's start off with Toyota and Honda hybrid electric car specifications, as they are the only car manufacturer who sell hybrid in Malaysia. Toyota has the Prius and Prius C. Honda has the Civic Hybrid, CR-Z, Insight and Jazz Hybrid.

Let's compare the 2012 Hybrids for their electrical property:
Car Model
Electric
Motor Type
Motor
Output (kW)
Battery
Voltage (V)
Current
( A = W/V)
Toyota Prius
AC
27
201.6
134
Toyota Prius C
AC
19.3
144
134
Honda Civic Hybrid
DC
20
108 - 172
116 - 185
Honda Jazz Hybrid
DC
10
100.8
99

Next, let's look at the battery location. Why battery location is important? You will find out in Part 2.

Toyota Prius:




Toyota Prius C:




Honda Civic Hybrid:




Honda Jazz Hybrid:


Note: Not much Honda Jazz Hybrid information available on the Internet during compilation.

As you can see from the pictures, battery packs and transmission cables are shielded, presumably (I'm unable to find detail information on this, but I believe it does).

What is EMF? How does EMF strength and effect correlate with AC/DC, voltage, current and distance? Is low frequency EMF harmful? What is the amount of low frequency EMF hybrid car produce?


Disclaimer: I'm an ordinary customer who intend to buy hybrid car and at the same time worry about the electromagnetic fields. I did some readout and would like to share and I do hope expert can help to clear the myth.